The Garden Community for Garden Lovers
 

Midlothian, United Kingdom Gb

All my life I have known this as "Rose of Sharon" I am not sure as it was my grandmother who told me. Can you tell me what it is really called as I have seen adverts for Rose of Sharon in PINK ? the pictures shown look like a Lavatera.....is there such a thing as a pink version of the picture I have shown.



Rose_of_sharon_august

Answers

 

This is not Rose of Sharon. I have posted a few Rose of Sharon pics in my gallery. Feel free to take a look.

21 Aug, 2015

 

Well, depends whether you're American or not, Nanwilson! In America, several plants are called Rose of Sharon (lord knows how anyone knows which plant they're talking about there), the commonest being Hibiscus. (And there are many more anomalies - Osmanthus is called Tea Olive over there...)

However, in the UK, Rose of Sharon is a common name applied to Hypericum varieties, and that's what you're showing in your photograph.

It may be that either you were looking at an American source when you saw the pink flowered thing, or that (horror of horrors) the American way of using one common name for more than one plant is being taken up here. If what you saw looked like a lavatera, that might be what it was, or it might have been Hibiscus. I wouldn't buy from the people advertising it on principle, personally - we've got enough trouble with our own common names without importing more! (apologies to Bathgate...)

There are Hypericums with pink or orange or red berries, but not with pink trumpet like flowers.

21 Aug, 2015

 

As Bamboo says, yours IS a Rose of Sharon (Hypericum), just as your grandmother said. There is no such thing as a pink-flowered Hypericum.

21 Aug, 2015

 

Aarrgghh! The reputation us horrible Yanks have! Variation in common names has been a problem worldwide for centuries, which is why botanists use Linnaeus' system, so they always know what plant they are talking about. Admittedly, the UK has less variability in the common names in use there, possibly due to the long influence of garden societies? In the U.S., the diversity of our population's origins, and the freewheeling nature of gardening publications here, with no one to tell an author "Oh, piffle! It is no such thing!"

21 Aug, 2015

 

Sorry, Tug! I answer questions on a US based site too, so that's how I know this stuff - but it does seem that Americans generally have a particularly strong aversion to using the Latin names. The first time I ID'd Osmanthus burkwoodii, it was met with some very puzzled questions/protestations, so I had to provide a link as proof...

As for common names here, they're just as much a pain as yours are...

21 Aug, 2015

 

lol! Rose of Sharon here is simply a hardy Hibiscus.

21 Aug, 2015

 

Not just botanists either, it is a problem in all areas of classification. And just to make things even more weird Prunella is a genus of plants as well as one of our native birds. Same with Epilobium, a plant and a beetle. Confused me as a student as at the time I understood the generic name couldn't be used across phyla. But it can.

21 Aug, 2015

 

That's what google thinks too, but to me its Hypericum calcynum, and your British Grandma was right.

21 Aug, 2015

 

...and Boston Cream Pie is actually a cake! What a crazy world we live in!

21 Aug, 2015

 

What kind of cake? (And don't say a cream cake...)

21 Aug, 2015

 

It's a dreamy cake! Yellow sponge cake with vanilla custard between the layers. Chocolate sauce covering the top and allowed to drizzle down the sides. One of my favorite desserts with coffee.

21 Aug, 2015

 

Wish I wasn't allergic to chocolate!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

21 Aug, 2015

 

And no cream! LOL...

21 Aug, 2015

 

OK you can have cream and put a cherry on it too!

21 Aug, 2015

 

Allergic to cream as well!

22 Aug, 2015

 

Thank you so much for everyones help - probably was an American website that I saw the pink one on xx

22 Aug, 2015

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?