By Bobdav
United Kingdom
which would be the best eating apple tree to get for to plant in my garden has a chalky soil
- 10 Jan, 2012
Answers
Recommend Spartan apples - sweet/sharp, very juicy, crisp. Check out ornamental-trees at leominster for varieties including step-over, espalier, trees etc. They also do bare root, potted and air pots.
10 Jan, 2012
Shows how tastes differ. I do not like Spartan at all.
Early one would be Katja (Katie) or Discovery, but there are hundreds to choose from.
10 Jan, 2012
If you are only having one check whether it is self pollinating, unless a neighbour has one close by.
10 Jan, 2012
We have chalky soil and grow lots of different apple trees quite successfully. For an eating apple, I would choose James Grieves every time - wonderful flavour, but as Owdboggy says, tastes certainly differ - I don't care much for Spartan, either!
10 Jan, 2012
Here we go again. I like James Grieves taste, but in the end we dug it out here as it rarely produced decent fruit as it was very prone to Scab in this garden.
Agree about needing to check up on fertilisation. Best to plant two compatible trees really.
11 Jan, 2012
we used to grow a james grieve apple on very light soil, and always had a good crop with no codling moth/scab or other problems etc; although we did have to water it a lot in the summer. we have now moved to very heavy soil with river mud just a few inches deep so we are a bit worried about scab. do agree though it is best to plant two compatible trees.
11 Jan, 2012
if you've only room for one tree I'd recommend a 'family tree' we inherited one 25 years ago and it always crops well with 3 different varieties on the same small tree-- they are grafted with varieties that pollinate each other
11 Jan, 2012
Also which colour of apple do you prefer? Green or Red? We have Greensleeves which is a lovely sharp, green eating apple, mid season.
11 Jan, 2012
That's a very, very good idea, Pamg. Can you order them from anywhere that lets you choose the varieties that are grafted together, or do you have to go with the nurseryman's choice?
12 Jan, 2012
No idea Gattina I don,t know our varieties but theres one on there which is small,red/yellow with yellow flesh that has to be eaten straight from the tree, do that and its crisp,juicy and such a lovely almost citrus flavour, leave it in a fruit bowl for just a day and it cotton wool......
12 Jan, 2012
I agree, Greensleeves is a lovely one, but don't know whether it needs a pollinater.
13 Jan, 2012
That depends on when you want to eat the apples. Most kinds will grow on chalk as long as you thoroughly prepare the soil to give the roots some depth of soil to grow into.
10 Jan, 2012