Will we have to dig out rubble or can we put topsoil over it?
By Katenancy
United Kingdom
Part of our new garden is covered with gravel, over weed control fabric, over a layer of hardcore/rubble. We would like to grow vegetables there. Will we have to get it all dug out of is there a way of growing on top?
- 19 Jul, 2009
Answers
Would be best to remove it, as much as possible. Unless you are going ot go for raised beds and 2 foot would be enough. But the trouble is rubble will let all rain throuhg and you wont have many worms in the soil which are what you need for good soil
19 Jul, 2009
well if theres tons of it then maybe raised beds but if your up for a good bit of digging over most plants as allen titchmarsh so rightly sais most plants naturaly have to deal with stones
19 Jul, 2009
darnit, I'd overlooked the worms.
How did that happen? I've always liked them so much.
19 Jul, 2009
If you want to grow root veg, potatoes, carrots, parsnips etc. then your going to need a deep bed of soil. I would definatly take the weed control fabric away and as much of the hardcore as possible but if your soil is a clay then put some of the gravel back in and mix it up well. This will improve drainage and stop everything becoming waterlogged.
Weeding, how could you ??
After everything the worms have done for us? Lol :~))
19 Jul, 2009
ow obviously take up the membrane i thaught that was obvious sorry
20 Jul, 2009
Ooops, sorry :~))
20 Jul, 2009
lol no worries
21 Jul, 2009
I would still push to get rid of as much hardcore as possible. Good luck :~))
21 Jul, 2009
YES I WOULD IF THERES LOADS
21 Jul, 2009
Thanks so much for the replies guys! I'll look into the raised beds, there are a few old railway sleepers lying around which might be useful..... Otherwise I think digging through it will be impossible without an actual digger. K
28 Jul, 2009
raised beds it is the sleepers are perfect
28 Jul, 2009
Previous question
« Just came up where I planted Echinacea seeds, green leaves with purply re tinges
The best way of growing on top could be in raised beds? If you have a search and a browse on this site, you'll see some photos and read about how others did it. Otherwise, I think it will only work if your layer of topsoil is really deep - at least 1ft, but 2 would be much better. If it's any shallower, the veg that needs more depth for its roots will struggle. Having said that, I'd have a go at growing runner beans up canes almost anywhere. As long as they get enough water and do not dry out.
19 Jul, 2009