By Catty4667
Essex,
United Kingdom 
hi all, need some id help please. my mum had this growing in her garden and told me it was wild garlic but im not sure, it does smell very garlicy though.
3 Jun, 2013
Answers
just had a look at pictures of wild leek and its still not quite the same. its the leaves again! thank you.
3 Jun, 2013
Spring onion?
3 Jun, 2013
wrong smell. it does smell of only garlic and not onion. this is turning into a mystery! definitely allium family though.
3 Jun, 2013
find a vampire and if it kills him/her its garlic. i should know i,m a bigonion
3 Jun, 2013
It looks like a welsh onion to me Catty. I grew some last year and this looks very like them.
3 Jun, 2013
If that's what it is its a perennial and should clump up like chives (unless this was the only one...)
4 Jun, 2013
im still unsure, my mum has contacted the person that gave it to her and now they say its an elephant garlic! we are going to wait a few months and pull up some more and see whats on the end of it! thank you all for the help, will edit this question in a few months!
5 Jun, 2013
Its going to have to grow a heck of a lot more to be elephant garlic!
6 Jun, 2013
thats what i thought! the person is a gardener as well, its very confusing! i think its definitely some sort of garlic due to the smell of it but thats as far as i go!
6 Jun, 2013
Previous question
The leaves don't look right for wild garlic. Could be wild leek.
3 Jun, 2013