The Garden Community for Garden Lovers
 
great

By Great

London, United Kingdom

Ive just found this plant in my vegetable bed. Please can you tell me what it is and should I remove it?




Answers

 

It is an allium. Some, but not all, can be invasive but if you only have the one then I would leave it for now. In a few years time you can remove it/them if it looks like a problem.

13 May, 2010

 

I think its rather pretty, thanks BB, have a few here and there just checked the whole garden. Not too many though

13 May, 2010

 

very nice be good near ya pond hint hint lol .

13 May, 2010

 

ok thats plant no 33! lol

13 May, 2010

 

lol xx

13 May, 2010

 

Warning from Dorjac. Don't be deceived by this innocent looking flower. In my garden they wrecked a large part of one of my borders. Ever seen the Disney film the sorcerers apprentice? All the brooms split up and start marching!!!!!!!! Dig it up search, search the soil and do not let it seed. It offsets minute bulbs too.......it can be a total pest.

14 May, 2010

 

lol but surley not so much of a concern for a nature area surley dorjac.

14 May, 2010

 

Depends on what you want out of a nature area. I thought this was a veggie plot, and do not invite stinking willie to grow on that. By the side of a stream in the wild .......OK. As Bulbaholic told me when I did my blog about this. It grows wild by a burn near him. A gardener could carry the minute bulblets in grooves on shoes and take then to a part of the garden that is not wild.

14 May, 2010

 

ow i see i was kind of asking a question so thanx for that dorjac xx .

14 May, 2010

 

It is growing in my veg patch Dorjac, Nosey was saying it would look nice in my wildlife area. Seen lots of very white bulbs. I'll take care thanks for the tip and yes I saw the film!!!

14 May, 2010

 

Dorjac if I collect what I can find and put them all in a pot and sink it in my wildlife area do you think that will contain them?

15 May, 2010

 

The trouble is Great, if it is stinking willie, it smells of onions. It seeds from those white flowers and has offsets of the tiniest bulbs you have ever seen. Its worst habit is...... it shows very early very early in the leafing cycle, the leaves get long and strappy, and flop all over other plants and smothers them. Then it waits until bluebells,,chionodoxa and epheion are on the way out,makes pointy little buds and pops up here and there with the white flowers. You hardly associate it with the nasty floppy leaves. It loves popping up in the middle of shrubs. Sneaky plant.

15 May, 2010

 

The plant I would call 'stinking willie' only has one or two flowers per head.

15 May, 2010

 

When it was growing I thought it was an onion as it looks the same leaves. It smells like an onion. Dont much like the name stinking willie!!! ha ha

16 May, 2010

 

i like the smell of onion to

16 May, 2010

 

Hi Nosey Ive sent you a pm

16 May, 2010

 

thanx great xx

17 May, 2010

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?