By Slimdil
Northumberland, United Kingdom
Identify these caterpillars please!
My nasturtiums are being decimated by these caterpillars. I don't really mind as I'd tried to clear this bed of nasturtiums anyway so they're helping me out. I just wondered what type they are. And are the little black eggs caterpillar eggs? Assume they are. Cabbage whites maybe? Sorry photos are a bit blurry - it was a bit windy when I took them!
- 15 Sep, 2016
Answers
The black bits are caterpillar poo!
15 Sep, 2016
Large cabbage white, if memory serves it's Pieris brassicae . Used to be one to study at O'level back in the 70's.
their eggs are yellow, long cylinders and you always find them under the leaf.
15 Sep, 2016
They look like tent caterpillars - they are highly social and highly destructive & will defoliate everything.
15 Sep, 2016
One of them has turned into a chrysalis on the wall behind our loo in the bathroom!
15 Sep, 2016
They are definitely not tent caterpillars and these are easy to identify as cabbage whites Bathgate. Tent caterpillars are a real problem here too especially at one of our local beauty spots.
16 Sep, 2016
I'm not so sure about that Sea- Cabbage Whites have yellow eggs. If you go back and read the post, the eggs here are black. Also these are Nasturtiums, not cabbages. Cabbage Whites like cabbage plants. They look like tent caterpillars.
16 Sep, 2016
They love nasturtiums too Paul. They are the most common one seen in our gardens and can destroy both brassicas and nasturtiums very quickly. They do not leave webbing at all.
16 Sep, 2016
The eggs are different too
16 Sep, 2016
the black eggs were assumed to be the caterpillar frass on the upper leaf surface. I did say their eggs were yellow in my first comment :o)
we plant nasturtiums along side brassicas as a sacrificial/companion plant to encourage the cabbage whites onto the nasturtiums and not the cabbages.
the uk tent species are more orangey and have orange hairs, these do not.
17 Sep, 2016
OK
17 Sep, 2016
Yes. Large white butterfly larvae - people use nasturtiums as sacrificial plants to attract the adults away from their brassicas.
15 Sep, 2016