By Melchisedec
Lancashire, United Kingdom
Is this a sucker?
My daughter has recently moved house and is gradually finding out about her garden. She assumed this stem on the left was a sucker, but now that it is flowering, she's not sure. What do you think?
- 1 Aug, 2013
Answers
Thanks, Honeysuckle! I don't think it can be a sucker with such a lovely rose on it - perhaps the bark mulch has been put on really thickly.
1 Aug, 2013
A sucker has 7 'lobes' (or whatever they're called) on it's leaves - like a wild rose. A 'non-sucker' (or whatever it's called) has 5 'lobes' (or whatever they're called)
Hope you can understand that lol :D
2 Aug, 2013
The suckers come from below the graft, from the rootstock
2 Aug, 2013
Thanks Hywel and Pamg. Before it flowered, we assumed it was coming from below the graft, because that's definitely how it appears, but it has only got 5 lobes (if that's what they're called!). If it's flowering like that, though, the same as the shoots above the graft, I think she'll just prune it normally. I'll suggest she removes some of the mulch and has a proper look.
2 Aug, 2013
That sounds right Mel, technically I think that the graft shouldn't be covered anyway as it does encourage suckers
2 Aug, 2013
It is just a nice new strong shoot, worth keeping.
2 Aug, 2013
Thanks Lizziebee! All things considered, that's what I think too.
2 Aug, 2013
Previous question
« ID please Thes are growing in my daughter's garden. Can anyone identify them...
Not really a rose person, I am sure there are loads of people on here who are. I bought some climbers (expensive but worth it) and one had a really long straight shoot appear which I decided was a sucker, hacked it off only to discover that that particular shoot was the one with the label on it - so definitely not a sucker!
Yours looks the same as the other flowers and you could incorporate it into the bush when pruning, but if its spreading too far out - just cut it off!
Now we will see what the real knowledgeable rose people say.
1 Aug, 2013