The Garden Community for Garden Lovers

Surrey, United Kingdom

I have Acer Shaina and Acer Little Princess and whilst the little princess one seems to just get on with it - the other one is either covered in blackfly, has dried out leaf tips and in general never looks very healthy - any ideas what I'm doing wrong? It is in partial shade but does get a bit of evening sun, is planted in ericaceous compost and is watered very regularly. Thanks.


On plant Acers


Answers

 

I suspect you may be watering too regularly, and the roots are waterlogged...can you check them?

30 Apr, 2010

 

As AmbleA says possibly overwatering...

30 Apr, 2010

 

Just looked it up and this Acer (shaina) seems a little difficult to grow - it hates to be over watered (check drainage in the pot), does better in a pot, is hardy, but prefers a fair bit of sun compared to most Acers. Hope that helps

30 Apr, 2010

 

Can't check the roots unfortunately but I would have thought it would turn yellow rather than white if overwatered?? When I made up the pot, I put in half a ton of stones at the bottom so I doubt that the drainage is bad. I will keep an eye on it and see. Thanks for all the suggestions though - I will persevere...

30 Apr, 2010

 

I hope there's a hole in the bottom of the pot - if not, that could be the cause. Turn it out of the pot and check

30 Apr, 2010

 

Don't worry bamboo - I actually did check and there is definitely a large hole in the bottom! Although I'm no expert I have learned that pots should have drainage having killed off a beautiful rose last year by not putting holes in the pot. I wonder if the spray I used for the black flies would cause the white tip problem?

30 Apr, 2010

 

Oh, white tips, from the first description I thought they were brown and withered. White discoloration is usually associated with wide temperature fluctuation - maybe the thing put out its leaves and then got cold. I'd be inclined to move it to a sunnier spot, see if that helps, since it seems to prefer a warmer situation.

30 Apr, 2010

 

OK, will do, but when it was in a warmer spot then the other leaves seem to get fried - seriously - I don't think you can win with this one! Thanks for all the advice.

30 Apr, 2010

 

Realistically the fussier Japanese acer's survive better planted in the ground - nice cool roots, easier to shelter. I often wonder why we are so bloody minded as to try to grow plants in out gardens that nature would not put there? Is it a bit like a woman who has curly hair and wants it to be straight? Whilst her sister with straight hair want curly hair....

30 Apr, 2010

 

I am that woman - long curly hair which I have straightened regularly! Perhaps that's why I subconciously chose this plant?! I think its more to do with the fact that I thought it was beautiful and I wanted it in my garden so I could see it all the time cos I'm greedy like that! Food for thought though MG.

1 May, 2010

 

Don't worry Muddywellies - I am just as bad! My hair is naturally wavy do I let it? Do I flip!

1 May, 2010

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?