The Garden Community for Garden Lovers
 

New York, United States

Who can ID this butterfly?




Answers

 

Small Tortoiseshell

30 Jul, 2017

 

Beautiful butterfly and the flower's not too shabby either.

30 Jul, 2017

 

Pretty sure its a Painted Lady.

30 Jul, 2017

 

Stera. you're right the black and white markings aren't right for a tortoiseshell

30 Jul, 2017

 

Yes it is a painted lady scientific name is Vanessa cardui.

we get them here too.

30 Jul, 2017

 

Thanks everybody. The flower is zinnia - a magnet for butterflies.

31 Jul, 2017

 

One summer a few years ago I counted 18 on my sweet rocket plants but although I continue to grow sweet rocket, I've seen no painted ladies since. I think it must have been a particularly good year for them. Am I right in thinking they are visitors from Spain?

31 Jul, 2017

 

Here in the US, they migrate up from Mexico. In your case it may be Spain.

31 Jul, 2017

 

North Africa in our case...

31 Jul, 2017

 

Penny I remember that year - we had crowds of them passing the side of our garden on their way to somewhere and quite a few stopped off to enjoy our Nepeta. Like you we haven't seen one since.

31 Jul, 2017

 

I only started seeing this one last year. Before that I haven't heard of "Painted Lady." Thanks for the info and interesting comments.

1 Aug, 2017

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?