The Garden Community for Garden Lovers

MISTAKEN IDENTITY!!

66 comments


Don’t you just hate it when you buy a plant and it turns out to be something different from the label – the wrong size, shape or even colour?

Or you buy bulbs or tubers and they grow into something unexpected?

I was thinking about this after a recent experience – and I thought I’d show you some of the ‘mistaken identities’ that have happened to me over the past few years.

A few years ago, I planted three ‘Bishop of Llandaff’ Dahlia tubers – you know the ones: tall, dark leaved with deep red flowers.

They were supposed to glow in my hot border. Imagine how silly these dwarf pale pink ones would have looked in there – because this is what actually came up!

That same year, I planted some supposedly red Cosmos seeds -

Hmmm…I don’t call that red, do you?

One of last year’s mistaken identities came in an order from a mail-order Nursery for a white Lavatera called ‘Lisanne’ which should have looked great next to my L. ‘Cynthia Nixon’.

Lavatera ‘Cynthia Nixon’

…but when it flowered, this is what I saw!

I’d also ordered three Phlox plants – purple ones called ‘The King’.

However, when they flowered, they were pink! A rather nice pink, I have to agree, but not ‘The King’…

Admittedly, the Nursery in question did send me a box of plants to make up for their mistakes – but it was annoying to get the wrong ones for my carefully planned scheme! Here’s one of the lovely plants I got as a compensation gift:

Marshallia mohrii

Last year, too, a lily which should have been ‘Centrefold’, which looks like this;

…came up like this!

It was a tiger lily – and clashed horribly with the mauves and pinks in the border around it.

Another mistake happened after I’d seen a beautiful climbing rose on GOY – called ‘Handel’. I went off and found one – so I thought – and planted it. When it flowered -

Well – that’s certainly not what I was hoping for! Wrongly labelled again!

Ah – that’s more like it…Louise and I removed every pot off the bench and checked the flowers to make sure I got the real thing!

And this year, as I really love Brodiaea ‘Queen Fabiola’, I ordered some more and planted them out in the expectation of seeing these beauties…

…but instead, up came some Allium ostrowskianum! I didn’t know what they were, and had to ask a question on GOY, as I didn’t remember planting any – but of course, they were in the border where ‘Queen Fabiola’ had supposedly been planted. Luckily, I liked them, and they’re pretty little flowers.

The worst case of ‘mistaken identity’ occurred just before I opened the garden in June this year. I have Papaver ’Patty’s Plum’ in a flowerbed, where she can show off in her beautiful silky gown. When I spotted a plant at a Garden Centre called ‘Frilly Patty’ I thought that it would complement ‘Patty’ and be a little different.

Papaver ’Patty’s Plum’

A liittle different! Mistaken Identity again – when the buds opened, the flowers were coral. Nothing like Patty at all, and worse, they made beautiful Patty look muddy and brownish in contrast. The plant just had to be shifted – I couldn’t bear the coral colour amongst the mauves and pinks of the flowers in that bed.

So I moved so-called ‘Frilly Patty’ across the garden where she looked a lot better with the Lysimachia ciliata as a background. I knew I was taking a big risk, moving a plant in full bloom – and I fear that it was a risk too far in this case – I don’t think that the plant has survived.

By the way, I did check out what the real ‘Frilly Patty’ should look like, and she’s very pretty…so I might risk another shot next year, if I come across her again. Let’s just hope it’s not yet another case of mistaken identity though.

More blog posts by spritzhenry

Previous post: A Flagship Garden...

Next post: Time for a revamp - Goodbye Cistus!



Comments

 

It's annoying isn't it ? Grrrr.
Your pictures look lovely though ! :-)
Did you see the 'Disappointing Dahlia' pictures i posted ? Should be Pinelands Princess and it's most definately not :-(((((((

5 Jul, 2010

 

Its sods law isn't it, they are never better than what you would have hoped for are they? I must say you have had more than your fair share of plant boobs Spritzhenry...

5 Jul, 2010

 

Great blog, it did make me laugh and I enjoyed your photos. Thank you

5 Jul, 2010

 

How annoying and time consuming to have to move them, eventually I would imagine. Louise very kindly pointed out that my photo of Aquilegia 'Winky blue and white' was not that at all, I found the label, compared it to the Aquilegia II had in bloom, nothing like it ! A very deep purple, pretty but not what I'd planned for. This was from a national GC chain.
The Brodiaea 'Queen Fabiola' and Allium ostrowskianum are of interest to me as I ordered 100 Summer bulbs through GW magazine, the blue Brodiaea are flourishing, yet the Allium (pink shade) have yet to appear ! None of the Freesias have shown up either. Grrrrr indeed ! : o (((((

5 Jul, 2010

 

very frustrating barbara isnt it when that happens, its happened to me a couple of times but not as much as you, still all lovely flowers even if not what they should be ;o)) lovely pics to barbara

5 Jul, 2010

 

Absolutely... I detest it! I bought a rose a few years ago because of the name on the label...just what I was looking for I thought...it turned out totally different, I was fuming....but could not take it out on the rose bush itself...I had to learn to accept it. She is alright, but not as beautiful.... :))

5 Jul, 2010

 

Oh Spritz, I think we have all been there in one way or another, and as you said, it is so annoying. You put a lot of trust in buying a purchase, and I can see how easily mistakes can be made, before a plant has flowered, but a little more care and attention by some of these places, would go a long way!

5 Jul, 2010

 

I've not had this many 'surprises' Barbara but have had a couple with Dahlias. Most memorable was a supposed dark leafed yellow dahlia which turned out green leafed pink and white. A bit of a disappointment in the 'red and yellow' border but it's now one of my favourites - and it's still in the same place!

5 Jul, 2010

 

Good for you, Lily! I'm glad you liked yours...maybe you got used to it, did you? I like my deep pink Phlox - but I'd still like purple ones. :-((

I know that some GCs use the excuse that customers move the labels around when they read a label - but I've found that most places staple them on these days, so I'm not at all sure about that particular one!

5 Jul, 2010

 

There'd be steam coming out of my ears if I'd had all these mistakes! I guess it's evidence of the sheer amount of plants you collect B, that you have had so many errors! The two Lavateras look the same to me....am I going mad or just blind? That poppy wasn't a nice one. Glad you found a better spot for it...if it survives. Allium Ostrow...is lovely! :))

5 Jul, 2010

 

Luckily I dont get too many but a Lobilia this year turned out to be a Delphinium!

5 Jul, 2010

 

Crikey I'm not visiting any of the garden centres you've been too Spritz Lol

5 Jul, 2010

 

The second (wrong) Lavatera was a little darker in colour, Karen, but it bit the dust in the winter. I didn't weep over it, I dug it out! :-)

Maybe it's because I 'do' buy a number of plants that I get 'mistakes' - but this set are spread over a few years, remember....not all this year.

Denise - I can't understand your particular 'mistaken identity' at all! They are sooooo different!

Hallo Fractal - well, at least I had a great and unusual set of plants from the mail order company as compensation! :-)))

5 Jul, 2010

 

It was sent to me in the post last year with a label that said 'Lobelia Russian Princess' it was about 2" high and green. I still have it - but its a delphinium or will be next year! I already had a Lobelia Russian Princess so knew what they are like.

5 Jul, 2010

 

I can empahise spritz - I've had loads of 'wrong' plants over the years. The latest is what I had thought was sorbus reducta for many years now turns out to be sorbaria sorbifolia :-(

5 Jul, 2010

 

Its especially frustrating when you plan your colour schemes to harmonise and compliment each other, I would be anoyed too with all those mistakes, having said that the plants themselves all look lovely Barbara.

5 Jul, 2010

 

Thanks, Pp. It is indeed annoying!
I do usually plan an area quite carefully - so having to change things isn't easy. I wondered how many other people had found that they got wrongly labelled plants!

5 Jul, 2010

 

I bought a young geranium Bertie Crug [magenta pink flowers and bronze leaves]. It has lovely bronze leaves and small white flowers. grrrr
I have had a few mislabeled plants too over the years.

5 Jul, 2010

 

I'm beginning to worry that I'll have the right plants in my garden Spritz! If knowledgeable gardens can buy the wrong ones what hope do I have? Lol

Another entertaining and thought provoking blog Spritz and the photos are excellent (as usual!)

5 Jul, 2010

 

its not that we buy the wrong ones its the mislabeling that does it. I often do a plant stall and people take the labels out to read it and then pop it back any where. One lady just popped it into the first/nearest pot to the front. when i asked her to put it back in the correct pot she said no as it wasnt what she wanted and walked off. grr grrr.

I dread to think what may have been sold un-knowingly incorrect. this is more of a worry when you have different colour forms of the same plant.

6 Jul, 2010

 

I didn't write my last comment very well, did I? Lol
I didn't mean that you buy the wrong plant but that you get so many labels mixed up by others.

Seeing as I buy my plants from supermarkets and B&Q I don't think I'll ever get the right one and I'll never know the difference! Lol

6 Jul, 2010

 

There isn't really an answer, unless you buy everything 'locally' when it's in flower, so you know 'exactly' what you're getting! The trouble is that if you want more unusual plants, you can only get them via mail order, and sometimes even the better Nurseries get it wrong, as some of us have found out. Very annoying!

6 Jul, 2010

 

As you say Spritz, it must be extremely annoying when you take so much time and put so much effort into your garden and your efforts are spoilt by one wrongly labelled plant.

I guess, as a total amateur, I don't have the same problems (as yet!) I would like to have co-ordinated borders and beds but I guess it will be ten years or so before I'm writing a blog like this! Lol

6 Jul, 2010

 

The way you work, Ian, I think it'll be MUCH sooner! Anyway, look at all the advice you have to hand now! LOL.

6 Jul, 2010

 

This is true Spritz, with all the great advice available here I will be able to have a great garden before to long. ;~))

6 Jul, 2010

 

How far have you got with removing the glass etc?

6 Jul, 2010

 

It's a slow job but we're getting there. I think we've decided to weed kill the whole lot and then rotavate it to level it off and start planting again next year. There are just to many nettles etc to do anything with it!

6 Jul, 2010

 

That's a shame - I've got some plants for you - will you be able to keep them in pots OK?

6 Jul, 2010

 

This blog made me giggle... very, very funny...
... Good one :o)

6 Jul, 2010

 

I think so Spritz, we have some very big pots which have held the likes of a vine, a delphinium and some lilies over the winter as well as some slightly smaller ones that had our platycodons (sp?) in. We do have the front garden where we can plant things temporarily! We want to concentrate on the back garden first as that is where we spend most of our outdoor time.

6 Jul, 2010

 

By the way did you get the PM I sent you?

6 Jul, 2010

 

Thanks, Tt! ;-) We all need to laugh sometimes, don't we....

Ian - I think so...I'll take a scroll...not a stroll, a SCROLL!!! lol.

Glad you'll be able to collect your plants...that's good.

7 Jul, 2010

 

Sh... I've tried several times to keep a serious face, reading through all your pics and captions, but I can't help but giggle at all those "surprise plants" ...

It's hilarious ... and well-written ...

... yes, we all need to laugh sometimes.. :o)))

7 Jul, 2010

 

You're very welcome to giggle - especially at the so called 'Bishop of Llandaff' which were about a foot tall - at the back of a 'hot' border! How pathetic is that! Poor little things - they got rescued and put in another place, but didn't survive the winter that year. And that lily! Well - really! I hated it...but it was funny as well....this huge spotted orange thing towering above my beautiful border! I can laugh about that, too. ;-)))))

7 Jul, 2010

 

May I suggest you print off this blog and show it to some of your visitors when you have your NGS Open Days ? It would illustrate in an amusing way, that gardening is far from straight forward .... Lol.. ;o)

7 Jul, 2010

 

Some of them are too busy asking raaaaather strange questions, Tt - and I try to keep a straight face and answer politely! I have a giggle later, though...;-)

7 Jul, 2010

 

When you are asked a strange question ...
... just hand the visitor a copy of this blog ...
... guaranteed to confuse ... ;o)

7 Jul, 2010

 

Now you've got me giggling, Tt! It certainly would confuse them...especially the man who mistook the Weeping Ash trees for Wisteria! LOL.

7 Jul, 2010

 

Lol... by the way, I replied to the pm you sent to me when you were away visiting..
no need for a reply.. just checking that your messages are getting through the mechanics of GoY :o)

7 Jul, 2010

 

Ooops! Sorry - I tried to 'borrow' my daughter's Applemac when she wasn't looking (or using it!) but it wasn't always possible. I 'think' I read it and then got turfed off.....thank you anyway...:-)))

7 Jul, 2010

 

These unwanted plants would look great in my garden would have a well looked after and cared and wanted home, would you like my address to send to .

I have been told always buy in flower you know what your getting then.

7 Jul, 2010

 

That's a very good idea if you're buying locally, 6d, but if it's a plant that's not generally stocked, and you have to get it by mail order, then you could have problems. Bulbs, seeds and tubers too - you look at the picture on the packet and hope the supplier got it right! They certainly don't always, as you've seen!

8 Jul, 2010

 

Then I would of stopped orering from the supplier at the first mistake, and complained and returned at their cost their mistake. Hence this is why I buy off ebay as you know what your getting and if not satisfied you can mark them and give a bad report which stops others having the same done on them. Or I ask my local nersery to order for me, then they are liable and local.

8 Jul, 2010

 

Yes - there's a good Nursery that will 'source' plants for me. That's where I got my Pieris this year. It's a bit annoying when reputable companies package Dahia tubers incorrectly, though - or Lily bulbs! Not a lot you can do about that, really, several months later when the plant flowers wrongly. :-((

8 Jul, 2010

 

I would still return it to them I know Wyevale garden centre will tell you to keep reciept even if it dies on you they will refund or swop .

8 Jul, 2010

 

Yes - ours is a good one, so I'm sure they would, but the plants I told you about in this blog are long gone now - apart from the ones that came mail-order, and they were very fair about it all and compensated me.

8 Jul, 2010

 

Its good you have found a good place and so they should compensate you from mail order.

8 Jul, 2010

 

I agree! :-)

8 Jul, 2010

 

:o)

8 Jul, 2010

 

This year I bought 3 apricot foxgloves on Ebay, (fancied soft apricot scheme) Gave good feed back as they were lovely, large, healthy plants, so excited as they opened...common purple jobbies:-( Seller did refund my money. Bought 3 double geraniums, only double jewel has opened so far, single little flower, haven't heard back from Van Meuwen yet. Great blog again Spritz, gave me chance to moan again . I thought patty's plum was a muddy brownish colour? Perhaps I've only seen it in the wrong setting. I bought some lily bulbs at Malvern, they haven't opened yet, but I think they are not what they are supposed to be either. Did you see Hampton Court this evening? Vicky's won another Gold and Plantagogo was featured...made me want more heucheras and heucherellas again, she now wants the national collection of tiarellas:-)

8 Jul, 2010

 

I seen it she had a wonderful collection of them

8 Jul, 2010

 

Wish I had - the Heuchera I got from her at Malvern is doing well.

Patty?? Muddy Brown?? Oooooohhhhhhh Ba. Shame on you! She's GORGEOUS.....Mind you, next to the coral one, she did look brownish, so it could well have been her companions that spoilt her true beauty when you saw her.

9 Jul, 2010

 

It really was very good wasn't it Sixpence:-) Barbara, I must let you know VanMeuwen have just let me know they are refunding the £20 + odd pence for the geraniums, and offered unequivical apology for my disappointment! So they must be ok company, I must say I have had no problems with them before, and shall of course do business with them again. I love a happy ending:-)

9 Jul, 2010

 

Well done! I'm pleased to hear that, Ba. :-))))))

9 Jul, 2010

 

I'm glad I'm not the only one that chuckled at this. Your whole garden look great to me

9 Jul, 2010

 

Thanks, Sandygirl - I don't mind a bit if people have a laugh - some of the 'mistakes' were funny!

10 Jul, 2010

 

Two possibilities - either you are suffering from the silliest nursery in history and a run of extraordinary bad luck - or you buy an incredible quantity of flowers - I rather suspect the latter!

11 Jul, 2010

 

How did you guess? LOL.

11 Jul, 2010

 

Oh dear, I know exactly what you mean, isn`t it annoying? :o(

21 Jul, 2010

 

Mind you, you DID make me laugh...lol! ;o))

21 Jul, 2010

 

I really don't mind! I wrote this blog with my tongue firmly in my cheek, but some of the mistakes were just a bit irritating! LOL.

21 Jul, 2010

 

Barbara, further to my comment about liliy bulbs bought at Malvern, they were supposed to be regale, for my perfumed round patio and muscadet, 'cos i like it. No flowers yet, but definitely not what I thought i had bought, hope they are beautiful anyway, but not bright orange!:-)

22 Jul, 2010

 

Ooops!!! More wrong labels, Ba?

I found 'a' lily at the back of the wide border - I planted a number of yellow tiger lillies there. This one is cream with spots, but not a tiger-lily shape at all! Not tall, either, so that's how I missed seeing it. :-((

Where the others are, I have no idea. :-(( Next year, they'll be in pots like 99% of the others I grow.

22 Jul, 2010

 

I think we must be fairly lucky reading this blog, only one mistake comes to mind one white hollyhock which should have been black, you must have made up for it though, I think someone is having great fun with you and your plants Spritz, have you got elves or fairies at the bottom of your garden?

23 Jul, 2010

 

Yep! Sure is Annoying, I have what was supposed to be a Blueberry bush and ended up as a big Non Edible Cherry Tree LOL Ha! It produced its first fruit this year...... WAIT! For it ' One Cherry LOL, It is still in a pot and isn't looking too happy but I'm not sure what to do with it as I haven't really the room for it, may have to give it away to someone who wants it.

24 Jul, 2010

 

Oh dear - a really BIG mistake there!

No, Dd....only badgers. Maybe they're getting their own back! LOL.

25 Jul, 2010

Add a comment

Recent posts by spritzhenry

Members who like this blog

  • Gardening with friends since
    20 May, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    1 Jun, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    5 May, 2010

  • Gardening with friends since
    1 Apr, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    1 Jul, 2010

  • Gardening with friends since
    3 Mar, 2010

  • Gardening with friends since
    9 Aug, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    7 Jun, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    31 Mar, 2010

  • Gardening with friends since
    21 Jun, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    8 Apr, 2010

  • Gardening with friends since
    14 Aug, 2008

  • Gardening with friends since
    24 Jul, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    22 Jan, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    13 May, 2010

  • Gardening with friends since
    23 Oct, 2009

  • Gardening with friends since
    27 Sep, 2008

  • Gardening with friends since
    30 Apr, 2009